Skip to content
You are here:
REVIEWS: "ORPHAN" VARIETALS PDF Print E-mail

Grapes you won't find everywhere

MAY 4 -- Ever spot an unusual wine in a winery tasting room -- a varietal that almost no one in Michigan grows? It's likely the winemaker has a special passion for the grape, or wants to see how it fares in our climate. These "orphans" -- varietals like Auxerrois, Kerner, Lemberger, Syrah or Viognier -- only rarely make their way to retail shelves or restaurant lists.

2007 Domaine Berrien Marsanne

The MichWine Tasters sampled 14 wines from vinifera (European) grapes, plus a hybrid varietal dessert wine. We review 12 of them, and Master Sommelier Claudia Tyagi suggests how to pair food with a group of different wines.

Our top wine, 2007 Domaine Berrien Cellars Marsanne, comes from a white grape native to France's Rhone Valley. The warm 2007 vintage provided just the conditions to ripen it fully. At 91 points, it made our "Excellent" category; several others followed just behind.

"ORPHAN" VARIETALS:  TWELVE WINES REVIEWED
        REVIEW NOTES by Sally Goldberg and the MichWine Tasters
        FOOD & WINE PAIRING by Master Sommelier Claudia Tyagi
        FAQ about MichWine's review procedures and tasting panel

Credit where it's due: Domaine Berrien provided samples of six different grapes, four from the Rhone Valley. They're clearly hard at work trying to establish new varietals in Michigan -- and judging from several of their scores, the work is paying off.

From the same French neighborhood, we tried two samples of Viognier, the grape of Condrieu. We very much liked the 2008 version from Domaine Berrien Cellars. Leelanau Peninsula's Chateau Fontaine sent a non-commercial sample from 2007; they plan to plant on a commercial-scale this year.

Among the reds, two wineries across the street plant the same grape, but one (Lemon Creek) calls it Shiraz, like the Australians, and the other (Domaine Berrien) calls it Syrah, like the French. We preferred the 2004 from Lemon Creek. We were also wowed by their 2007 Kerner, a Riesling cross from Germany. This seems like a natural for other Michigan wineries to try.

Two up-north wineries make wine from the Alsace varietal Auxerrois. For the second year in a row, Chateau Fontaine came up a winner, though we may have tasted a flawed bottle from Bel Lago.

Also tasted, but not reviewed:
2007 Lemberger, Domaine Berrien Cellars, Lake Michigan Shore
2006 Syrah, St. Julian "Braganini Reserve", Lake Michigan Shore
2007 Viognier, Chateau Fontaine, Leelanau Peninsula (not a commercial release)

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (2)


Show/Hide comments
...
Joel and Sally, great idea for a tasting and article. Curious why the St.Julien Braganini Syrah wasn't included because that is one of the best Michigan reds I have ever had. Perhaps it was sold out?
Keep me in mind for your panel in the future. I am a big fan of Lemberger, and Kerner is one of my favorite hybrids. Did you know that Trollinger is a red grape?
Hope to see you at the All Canadian judging next week.
Bobby Frank
bobby j. frank , May 08, 2009
Orphan reviews
Bobby, thanks for your comment. We opened a bottle of the Marsanne last night with some friends who'd never tried it, and they were blown away. I'm also a great fan of the Lemon Creek Kerner and thought the Woodland White was a very credible follow-up to the award-winning 2007, given the differences in weather between the vintages.

The two reasons we would not publish reviews are if the panel scores a wine below 80 points or if we taste something that's not a commercial release (like the Fontaine Viognier). Obviously a difference of opinion on the Braganini Syrah...
Joel Goldberg , May 09, 2009 | url

Write comment

smaller | bigger
security image
Write the displayed characters

busy
 
< Prev   Next >

Joel Goldberg's Blog

New posts every Tuesday, sometimes more or less often

"NO, THANKS" TO JUDGING

thompson-dawson.jpg

New York wine writers Lenn Thompson and Evan Dawson won't judge at wine competitions, and urge other journalists to follow suit. The complaints are valid -- but their prescription doesn't work for states like Michigan.

WEATHER FLIP-FLOP, 2010

So far, Michigan's warm, early-maturing 2010 vintage looks like a winner for red wines -- while California is suffering one of its coolest summers in years.

A "WHAT-IF?" FANTASY

Two high-profile politicians who carried water for Michigan's wine wholesaler cartel lost big in the primary for Governor. So let's take a trip into fantasyland, where politicians do what's good for the state, rather than their contributors.

KNOW A GOOD BYO? PLEASE SHUT UP!

Michigan's consumer-unfriendly laws make most BYO illegal. So publicizing places that quietly allow it doesn't necessarily do them any favors.

Robert Hodgson
Wine competitions may hate the name Robert Hodgson. He's putting numbers to longtime concerns about judging quality and consistency.

GUESS WHO CRASHED THE PARTY?

Cellar reduction partyYes, thank you, I believe I WILL try some Michigan Cabernet Franc next to that '86 Cheval Blanc

OLD MISSION'S CAPE CONNECTION

Coenraad Stassen's license plate

Mere coincidence that Old Mission's two South African-trained winemakers grabbed all the awards at the Cab Franc Challenge? Maybe not...

WINE WRITING'S ETHICAL THICKET

Why does wine writing tolerate murky ethics and apparent conflicts of interest that wouldn't be acceptable in other areas of journalism? The new AnnArbor.com is the latest media outlet to ignore such concerns.

HAS TERRY STINGLEY FOUND MICHIGAN'S "IDENTITY WINE"?

Terry Stingley

Kalamazoo retailer Stingley believes Cab Franc has the chops to become our state's flagship. And he's organizing a one-of-a-kind event to help make it happen.

MichWine Classics

Larry Mawby Ode to the Leelanau Winemaking pioneer Larry Mawby pens a poem about his home

Jim LesterThe South Will Rise! Wyncroft's Jim Lester likes his region's future

Login / Register






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register